Skip to main content

In Shaking Up Shakespeare, crunchy conversations on casting abound

int(91910)
iPhoto caption: From left: Hope Van Der Merwe, Liam Lockhart-Rush, Ho Ka Kei (Jeff Ho), and Dr. Marlis Schweitzer.
/By / Jan 15, 2024
SHARE

How might we cast Shakespeare in 2023 and beyond — besides in marble? 

That’s just one of the questions on the mind of Shaking Up Shakespeare, a new podcast about the ongoing negotiation of Shakespeare’s legacy in Canadian theatre. I sat down with the podcast’s creators — Dr. Marlis Schweitzer, Hope Van Der Merwe, Liam Lockhart-Rush, and Ho Ka Kei (Jeff Ho) — to chat about the origins and aims of the project. The podcast is part of a larger initiative through York University, led by Schweitzer, called (Re)Setting the Stage: The Past, Present, and Future of Casting Practices in Canada. 

Shaking Up Shakespeare began as an attempt to document the 2022 touring production of Why Not Theatre’s Prince Hamlet, directed by Ravi Jain. This groundbreaking production was bilingual, incorporating English and American Sign Language on equal footing, and positioning Deaf actor Dawn Jani Birley as Horatio at the centre of its narrative. In fact, it defied the norms of Shakespearean casting, not only with regard to access, but also race, culture, age, and gender. Ho Ka Kei (Jeff Ho), a queer Asian man, played Ophelia in the production.

While on the road, Ho interviewed his collaborators about the tour as well as previous iterations of the production. Ho’s full interview with Dawn Jani Birley in ASL is available on the (Re)Setting the Stage website, and the entire Shaking Up Shakespeare podcast will be available in ASL translation, with the first three episodes already posted on YouTube.

In our conversation, Ho reflected on “the chance to be onstage with this travelling group of artists, and then find a little space in a corner in a hotel” to record his fellow theatremakers. In such an ephemeral artform, this was a rare opportunity “to archive both…the tour itself,” said Ho, “but also questions around…why Shakespeare now?” 

Those questions soon expanded beyond the bounds of Prince Hamlet. The Shaking Up Shakespeare team found themselves interviewing over 30 theatremakers and scholars about their relationship to the Bard and his works. Unsurprisingly, responses ranged from outright rejection, to ambiguity, to irreverent optimism. 

Schweitzer stressed the ways in which colonial projects have co-opted Shakespeare’s plays to “prop up colonialism [and] white supremacy, and to support very particular notions around gender, race, sexuality [and disability] that have been used, historically, to undergird those structures of power.” 

Schweitzer compared this version of Shakespeare to a milk bath, insofar as “there’s this idea of luxury and…the sense that Shakespeare is only accessible to certain people [and]…will enable a kind of white performance.” 

Shakespeare is there. The question becomes, what are we going to do about it?

Van Der Merwe pointed out that even the language of scansion — which syllables should be stressed or unstressed in Shakespeare’s verse — has patriarchy baked into it. Students in theatre training programs learn about so-called “feminine endings…meaning that the line ends on a weak beat,” explained Van Der Merwe, as opposed to “masculine endings,” where the line ends on a strong one. 

On the other hand, “if you live in Anglophone Canada,” said Schweitzer, “you will be inundated with [Shakespeare] in some form or other, whether it’s tourist mugs with Shakespeare’s face, or in newspaper accounts of some production…or just in everyday speech.”

Ho agreed. “For a lot of racialized artists, [Shakespeare] is also part and parcel with the education system having grown up in, or studied in, Canada,” he said. “You are embedded in it from high school onward.” 

“Especially if you’re looking to work at the Stratford Festival, which is a gigantic institution,” said Lockhart-Rush, “it’s important to teach people who want to work as actors in Canada…techniques for working with Shakespeare.” He went on to note that, for better or for worse, proficiency with Shakespeare is often “measured as a type of success” for actors.

Van Der Merwe added that there are also practical economic incentives to revive and adapt Shakespeare’s work: “you don’t have to pay royalties on it, so it’s cheap to produce.”

“Shakespeare is there,” said Schweitzer. “The question becomes, what are we going to do about it?”

This query becomes the major focus of Shaking Up Shakespeare. Besides an episode devoted to Prince Hamlet, listeners can expect an interview with Debbie Patterson, who became the first disabled person in Canada to play Richard III, in Shakespeare in the Ruins’ 2016 production; an exploration of Amaka Umeh’s trail-blazing performance as a Black, non-binary Hamlet at the Stratford Festival in 2022; and more.

Each of these productions — and their respective approaches to casting — demonstrate how, in Schweitzer’s words, Shakespeare can be a “Trojan horse” for artists who want to tell new stories and increase representation on Canada’s stages. 

She cited Erin Shields’ Queen Goneril — a prequel to King Lear which premiered at Soulpepper in repertory with the original text in 2022 — as an example of this kind of considered adaptation, both in terms of narrative and casting. Shields’ play reimagines Shakespeare’s villain, not only as a protagonist, but as a Black queer woman (played by Virgilia Griffith in the premiere production). 

“Everybody knows King Lear,” said Schweitzer. “Soulpepper staged King Lear and Queen Goneril [as a double bill]. So people who are maybe only interested in Shakespeare could come and see it, but if they were interested in a new play, a feminist interpretation, they could go and see Shields’ brilliant reworking.” Listeners can hear Shields discuss her adaptation in episode six of the podcast. 

In our interview, Lockhart-Rush offered Cliff Cardinal’s Governor General’s Award-winning As You Like It as another example of “Trojan horse” Shakespeare. The initial production of Cardinal’s play purported to be a straightforward adaptation of As You Like It — only to reveal itself as anything but. “It [drew] in those crowds who maybe…don’t see much theatre in Toronto, but they love to go to Stratford and they love to see [a Shakespeare play] every year,” said Lockhart-Rush. [Then] they come to [Cardinal’s play] and they’re exposed to things that they maybe haven’t considered, or perspectives…they need to reconsider.”

Perhaps the future of Canada’s relationship to Shakespeare is one in which every artist, no matter their intersections, can bring all of themselves to engage with the Bard. “There’s often an absence in how we talk about Shakespeare that everyone has alluded to,” said Ho. “When I take on Ophelia, am I playing ‘my fair Ophelia?’ Am I playing a fair-skinned character? Or am I who I am, bringing all of my intersectionality?”

Ho — whose acclaimed play Cockroach was also a wrestling match with Shakespeare’s omnipresence — made it clear that this intersectional approach is by no means a tidy solution to a problem. Rather, it is only the beginning of more “passionate, and sometimes painful, crunchy” but necessary conversations. 

“When folks grapple with these questions from different perspectives,” said Ho, “it can be an act of reclamation…[or] it can be a complete rejection, and that is completely valid as well.”

“But why Shakespeare now?” he continued. “Because that crunchiness can be such fuel for artistic generation.” That same crunchiness is what makes Shaking Up Shakespeare such a vital listen. 


Shaking Up Shakespeare is accessible on Spotify and Apple Podcasts as of January 15.

Nathaniel Hanula-James
WRITTEN BY

Nathaniel Hanula-James

Nathaniel Hanula-James is a multidisciplinary theatre artist who has worked across Canada as a dramaturg, playwright, performer, and administrator.

LEARN MORE

Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


/
theresa cutknife iPhoto caption: Theresa Cutknife headshot by Dahlia Katz.

Speaking in Draft: Theresa Cutknife

“Of course, we all have to make money and make different sacrifices just to pay the bills, because this city is so horribly overpriced,” says Cutknife. “But why? Why do we have to suffer to feel like we’ve paid our dues to the industry?”

By Nathaniel Hanula-James
guild festival theatre iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of Guild Festival Theatre.

A beloved trio returns to Scarborough’s Guild Park in Three Men on a Bike

“What have I personally got to do with these guys?” asks director Sue Miner. “Nothing, and yet I love them and I love their journey. They just touch people to come along for the ride. That’s part of the draw for me. They [screw up] for us so we don’t have to. We can just sit and enjoy and laugh at their foibles. Anything that brings us all back to humanity is my hero right now.”

By Nathaniel Hanula-James

Inside three mouth-watering shows at Toronto Fringe 2024

Intermission sat down with the creative masterminds behind three highly anticipated Fringe shows to get the inside scoop on what goes into creating a smash hit.

By Mira Miller
mary's wedding iPhoto caption: Derek Ritschel, director of Mary's Wedding and artistic director of Lighthouse Festival Theatre.

Mary’s Wedding promises to pack an emotional punch at Lighthouse Festival Theatre

“I liken it more to poetry than I do to your standard text of a play,” says Derek Ritschel, the director of Mary’s Wedding and the artistic director of Lighthouse Festival.

By Nathaniel Hanula-James
balancing act iPhoto caption: The Balancing Act team. Photo by Zeeshan Safdar.

Balancing Act creates options for caregivers in Canadian theatre

“The policies that we're creating, while they're centring mothers, parents, artists who are caregivers, they actually help everyone in the industry,” says founder and executive director Lisa Marie DiLberto. “You don't know when you're going to need these kinds of supports, because everyone's going to be a caregiver or need care at some point.”

By Kaitlyn Riordan
erum khan iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of Erum Khan.

Speaking in Draft: Erum Khan

"[Buddies] is full of so many tensions," says Khan. "It’s full of so much history. I’m trying not to go in naively in a way that’s like, ‘let’s revolutionize this place and radically shift it overnight.’"

By Nathaniel Hanula-James