REVIEW: The Legend of Daddy Hall feels like coming home
iPhoto caption: Photo of Come Home — The Legend of Daddy Hall by Cylla von Tiedemann.
I’ve said it before and I will say it again: Toronto theatre, you are getting it right, and I love that for us!
I didn’t realize how much going to the theatre could become healing — and we could all benefit from more healing in our lives. The stories of our Black and Indigenous ancestors filled the walls on opening night at the Tarragon Theatre Mainspace, reminding us of the lands and waters they’ve crossed and stewarded. Come Home — The Legend of Daddy Hall is an invitation for reclamation not bound by space or time. This intricate story filled with playful delight and integrity could satisfy the excitement of any theatre-goer. During rehearsal for the show, director Mike Payette called it an “ancestral fantasia.” I’d call it a belonging, an aural mélange of memory coming together.
Based on the true-life figure John “Daddy” Hall, the play stages the non-linear journey of this legendary Canadian as he faces himself — but not without his ancestral team guiding him along the way. From water to land, Hall’s journey is lengthy and at times mysterious, as the play weaves through time, space, and realms, to arrive right where it began. This is a story of a human’s journey of love and survival.
John “Daddy” Hall was said to be born of Jamaican and Mohawk ancestry around 1780 in Amherstburg, Ontario, before he was captured and enslaved in Virginia and Kentucky. Legend says he then escaped back to Ontario, where he eventually died in Owen Sound at a rumoured 117 years of age. This world premiere play is not a historical text — there is very little information about who this man really was. Rather, playwright Audrey Dwyer has brought Hall to life by creating a world where we witness a human navigate pain and heartache through sheer determination.
From watching his mother take her own life when they were taken into slavery, to his first wife falling through the ice while they escaped back to Canada, Hall dreams of having a life different from what he’s seen, and at the end of his life, he relives those memories to understand how to support the generations to come.
This play moves quickly as it travels through the past, present, and future. Ancestors, spiritual guides, the universe, all have their hands in making sure everything is going to plan, even if it looks like it’s all falling apart!
The play starts with Hall (a vibrant and generous Daren A. Herbert) entering the spiritual realm. Under a purple hue and a soft spotlight, he lies centre stage. And once the veil is lifted, we see a multi-levelled set, filled with cracks and crevices designed by Jawon Kang. Coupled with Michelle Ramsay’s lighting design that encapsulates time moving from sunset and sunrise. The live music by Unsettled Scores (Spy Dénommé-Welch and Catherine Magowan), is played above the stage. They have an assortment of instruments including flute, electric guitar, bass, and many more. The music was atmospheric and transported you from scene to scene: from the swamp, to the boat, to the plantation.
Only 90 minutes in length, the play is full of personality. The women in Hall’s life — Mary (Helen Belay), Elizabeth (Nicole Joy-Fraser), and Ma (Emerjade Simms) — loved him so deeply, but were never afraid to remind him of his ways. “Daddy” Hall is stubborn and didn’t always listen to the people he loved most, and often made decisions that benefited only himself. (Hall had to reconcile with both those truths.)
Simms brings Ma to life and shows her dialect range by tapping into her Jamaican ancestry, and Belay shines as Mary by embodying the poetic text. Joy-Fraser reveals her experience as an actor through the calm yet direct demeanour she brings to Elizabeth.
The relationship between Pa (Brandon Oakes) and Hall is tender and loving. While each character represents the past and the present, Billie played by Troy Adams represents the future. (Adams’ character offered witty criticism of what it’s like to experience everyday microaggressions as a Black and Indigenous Canadian.) Billie retells stories of what he witnessed his child experience in school and the prejudice he received for how he looked. Adams’ character speaks of the injustice in the world and reminds us of how to not continue them.
One of the most intriguing elements of the play is its use of language. Guided by Indigenous dramaturge Monique Mojica, the actors mainly spoke English, but also Mohawk. Hall was an interpreter during the War of 1812, and he was said to have been fluent in several languages. This added detail comforted me. The sound of different languages and dialects created a familiar space, one that I was accustomed to growing up as a first generation Canadian with Caribbean (Afro-Guyanese and Amerindian) ancestry. It also reminded me most of today’s Toronto, and all the many languages that are spoken here.
Home is not a place, it’s a feeling, and Come Home — The Legend of Daddy Hall feels like I came home. I was taken on a journey watching this play and came out honoured to be a witness to such an incredible story. I encourage you to do the same.
Come Home — The Legend of Daddy Hall runs until June 9. Tickets are available here.
Intermission reviews are independent and unrelated to Intermission’s partnered content. Learn more about Intermission’s partnership model here.
Aisha Lesley Bentham
Aisha Lesley Bentham BFA, MA is an internationally trained artist-scholar, vegan chef, and wellness coach. Aisha’s research and passion examines the intersections of cooking and performance and aims to integrate notions of care, eco-somatics, and cookery from the perspective of a first-generation Black Canadian. Her new work will premiere at SummerWorks August 2023.
LEARN MORE
iPhoto caption: 'Vampyr.' Photo by Nicolas Calderon.
REVIEWS: Festival TransAmériques 2026
The 20th edition of Montreal’s FTA does right by its name, featuring a curated lineup of 25 theatre and dance productions with roots mostly in the Americas. This year, Intermission presents its most comprehensive FTA coverage ever, with four critics publishing a total of 16 capsule reviews — responses that will appear below over the course of the two-week festival.
iPhoto caption: Photo courtesy of the Canadian Opera Company.
REVIEW: Aportia Chryptych marks many firsts for Canadian opera
While representation is important, re-telling stories of Black Canadians comes with even greater responsibility. Our stories are not monoliths, nor should they exist within a digestible social narrative. Imbued with...
iPhoto caption: Photo by Roya DelSol.
This play is such a delight to watch, and I would definitely go again. I live for this quality of performance, and I’m looking forward to how this play will continue to inspire Black Canadian theatre to come.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: Three Sisters weaves together joy, fear, and the Biafran Civil War
In this conversational review of Three Sisters, contributors Kemi King and Aisha Lesley Bentham reflect on a masterful production helmed by Mumbi Tindyebwa Otu.
iPhoto caption: Photo by Jae Yang.
REVIEW: In 3 Fingers Back, Donna-Michelle St. Bernard explores the extremes of war
3 Fingers Back ain't no regular play about war. We don't see or hear the destruction of the land or the cry of the people. Instead, Donna-Michelle (DM) St. Bernard's double bill of plays is more intimate, an inward crawl to what she calls the repetitive stress patterns that constitute the world.
Think of both of these plays not side-by-side but instead facing each other and reflecting to us, the audience.
After 12 wild and wonderful days of theatre, the 2023 Toronto Fringe has come to an end. Read our mini reviews here!
Comments