Announcing the winners of the 2024 Nathan Cohen Awards
The Canadian Theatre Critics Association (CTCA) has announced the winners of the 2024 Nathan Cohen Awards for Excellence in Critical Writing, including two writers from Intermission.
There are three awards categories: outstanding review, outstanding critical essay, and outstanding emerging critic.
This year’s awards for outstanding review and critical essay were adjudicated by Peter Marks, retired chief theatre critic for the Washington Post. The award for outstanding emerging critic was chosen by Ilana Lucas and Jamie Robinson, winners at last year’s awards.
The Nathan Cohen Award for outstanding critical essay went to Stephanie Fung for “The spectacle of suffering: Toronto theatre’s addiction to trauma porn,” published by Intermission on June 14.
Fung’s essay was a standout in a field of strong entries, Marks wrote. It “does what criticism is supposed to do: alert the arts community and the reading public to a vital (and in this case, confounding) trend, analyzes it, cites examples, offers a compelling argument, and accomplishes it all in gripping (and entertaining) style. The writer sends up a warning flare to the theatre world, advocating a course correction in provocatively convincing terms.”
This is Fung’s second Nathan Cohen Award, having last year taken home the prize for outstanding emerging critic.
In the outstanding review category, Toronto Star arts critic and reporter Joshua Chong won for his review entitled “The Last Timbit, the new Tim Hortons musical, may be the brand’s worst publicity stunt ever,” published by the Star on June 28.
“This review is a demonstration of one of the critic’s most important tools: wit,” Marks wrote. “A Tim Hortons musical might be an easy target, but when such a project is skewered deftly and delectably, it forges a special bond between writer and reader. It also supports the critic’s key function: giving their audience fair warning. What makes the review more than a hit job is that it does take fair measure of what is on the stage, and gives plenty of justification for the judgment. A delightful, hilarious read.”
And the Nathan Cohen Award for outstanding emerging critic has gone to Haley Sarfeld for “TK Fringe brings a strong mélange of summer shows to Kingston,” a file of capsule reviews published by Intermission on August 10.
“Having never been to the Kingston Fringe Festival before, [the] beautifully diverse range of show options made me want to run, not walk, to next summer’s event,” wrote Robinson. “[Sarfeld’s] advocacy for all the hard work that artists go through to make their magic soar, no matter the size of the venue, was a wonderful blend of storytelling and criticism that any reader, theatregoer or otherwise, could enjoy and comprehend fully.”
“Sarfeld’s collection of reviews for the Kingston Fringe, focusing on Kingston-based artists, packed a lot into its five shorter critiques,” affirmed Lucas. “Sarfeld’s facility with language is evident, with a unique lede for each review and specific, detailed observations that clearly describe not only the premise of each show, but the experience of attending it. As a reader, I immediately knew which of these shows would be to my taste. Sarfeld balances intellectual critique with a conversational tone. Each review is bite-sized (well, maybe two or three bites), but, as she writes in one of her capsule reviews, ‘it’s a voracious, mouth-watering bite!’”
The Nathan Cohen Awards have been given out since 1981. A complete list of past winners may be found here.
iPhoto caption: Mike Nadajewski in 'All the Cows Are Dead.' Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: Two critics compare reactions to TIFT’s new musical All the Cows Are Dead
Liam wrote about observing the production's rehearsal process. Shivani viewed the musical without any insider knowledge. On the way home from seeing the show in Barrie, they discuss.
iPhoto caption: Louise Pitre in 'Kimberly Akimbo.' Photo by Emelia Hellman.
REVIEW: Mirvish’s well-cast Kimberly Akimbo never stops surprising
The simple and the unconventional meld radiantly throughout Jeanine Tesori and David Lindsay-Abaire's Tony Award-dominating 2021 musical.
iPhoto caption: Athena So, Mike Nadajewski, Taylor Garwood, and Ben Page in rehearsal for 'All the Cows Are Dead.' Photo by Dahlia Katz.
What I discovered at rehearsals for TIFT’s world premiere musical All the Cows Are Dead
I’m sure most new musicals have interesting rehearsal processes — but it helped my excitement level that All the Cows Are Dead is a site-specific, existential two-hander from one of Ontario’s most risk-taking companies. There'll also be countless balloons.
iPhoto caption: L to R, top to bottom: 'The 39 Steps' (photo by Raph Nogal), 'Benevolence' (photo by Jae Yang), 'The Born-Again Crow' (photo by Jeremy Mimnagh), 'Dimanche' (photo by Thomas Müller), 'Last Landscape' (photo by Fran Chudnoff), 'The Merchant of Venice' (photo by Kyle Purcell), 'Slave Play' (photo by Dahlia Katz), 'Waiting for Godot' (photo by Elana Emer), 'The Welkin' (photo by Dahlia Katz).
Twelve indelible moments of performance from 2025
With the lights fading on another year of fleeting thrills in dark rooms, we asked 12 Ontario performing arts writers to reflect on a moment that stayed with them. The results mainly stem from Toronto theatre productions, but there are a few surprises weaved in.
iPhoto caption: Connor Mitton and members of the company of 'Sex Dalmatian’s Hot Holiday Spectacular.' Photo by Jeremy Mimnagh.
REVIEW: Sex Dalmatian’s Hot Holiday Spectacular is a peppermint-coated acid trip
Rock Bottom Movement’s surrealist mandate is on full display in this 15-dancer fantasia, which begins with an invitation to let go: “The only thing you need to know is not to know anything at all,” pronounces the Mayor of Sex Dalmatian, the evening’s narrator and the mayor of the titular canine’s mind.
iPhoto caption: Tom Rooney in 'Rogers v. Rogers' at Crow's Theatre. Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: Tom Rooney dazzles in world premiere of Michael Healey’s Rogers v. Rogers
Rooney and Healey skewer the Rogers family with a disarmingly relaxed virtuosity that the surrounding Crow's Theatre production sometimes supports, and sometimes lets down.
Comments