REVIEW: There are no words for Audra McDonald at Roy Thomson Hall
iPhoto caption: Photo by Jag Gundu
Any critic tasked with reviewing Audra McDonald must confront language’s inadequacy. Adjectives like “brilliant” and “heart-stopping” confuse her with the swaths of lesser performers who’ve been described similarly, flattening the matter. Her greatness is so established, so obvious, that such declarations feel empty. And yet to avoid them is to risk understatement.
Her touring concert An Evening with Audra McDonald, which played at Roy Thomson Hall on November 2 with the Toronto Symphony Orchestra, blurs descriptive poles: the singer’s manner is laid-back though poised, the selections predictable yet profound, her voice controlled but free. McDonald has collaborated with conductor Andy Einhorn for over a decade, and their act glistens with polish.
Perhaps unsurprisingly for a six-time Tony winner (the most of any actor), the concert includes many showtunes. Act One trends toward standards — “Summertime,” “It Don’t Mean a Thing (If It Ain’t Got That Swing),” “I Could Have Danced All Night” — while Act Two gets a bit more contemporary, to the point that it features a song found on R&B singer Emily King’s TikTok.
Much of the show orbits notions of childhood. McDonald sings “Pure Imagination” because she used to love Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, tells many a story about her four children, and invokes Kermit the Frog with a “Bein’ Green” cover. This exploration climaxes with a mash-up of “Carefully Taught” from Rodgers and Hammerstein’s South Pacific and “Children Will Listen” from Sondheim’s Into the Woods, two numbers highlighting how young people are shaped by their environments.
That song pairing has a hidden biographical resonance: Hammerstein was Sondheim’s writing mentor, his own careful teacher.
The program includes other subtle nods at the artistic lineage of American musical theatre. McDonald sings “Fable” from The Light in the Piazza — which, she points out, was written by Rodgers’ grandson, Adam Guettel. And a Bernstein medley (“Some Other Time” / “Somewhere”) follows a Sondheim one (“What Can You Lose?” / “Not A Day Goes By”), reminding us of the duo’s collaboration on West Side Story. This material is standard for a musical theatre concert, but it feels different in McDonald’s hands because she’s directly worked with many of these writers, making her part of the family. Especially in the case of Sondheim, her interpretations feel rooted in the man and his spirit (“We miss him terribly,” she says).
What gets me about McDonald is her phrasing. She’s performed most of this repertoire for several years, and her delivery is both sublime and mature. Whereas many musical theatre singers wander into vibrato haphazardly, spontaneously adding it halfway through a note, McDonald largely restricts such transitions to held-out vowels at the end of songs. Most other notes are either entirely straight, or entirely vibrato. This careful juxtaposition between (poppy) tension and (operatic) release gives McDonald’s storytelling its exhilarating texture.
An Evening with Audra McDonald includes a handful of songs from the singer’s most recent solo album, 2018’s Sing Happy. As the concert winds down, a thesis related to that title emerges: live in the moment. Love today. It’s not an original message; but with McDonald’s voice filling the air, it’s more achievable than ever.
An Evening with Audra McDonald played at Roy Thomson Hall on November 2. More information is available here.
Intermission reviews are independent and unrelated to Intermission’s partnered content. Learn more about Intermission’s partnership model here.
Liam Donovan
Liam is Intermission’s senior editor. He lives in Toronto. His Substack newsletter is available at loamdonovan.substack.com.
LEARN MORE
iPhoto caption: Tracey Nepinak and Teneil Whiskeyjack in 'Strife.' Photo by Jae Yang.
REVIEW: Punctuate! Theatre’s Strife opens up perspectives on grief, activism, and the oil industry
Playwright Matthew MacKenzie and director Yvette Nolan have crafted a drama in which every character is worth hearing. What follows is my attempt to listen — perspective by perspective.
iPhoto caption: Shira Leuchter in 'The Haunting' at Tarragon's Greenhouse Festival in 2024. Photo by Matt Hertendy.
REVIEW: One-on-one play considers the hidden meanings behind ghost stories
Shira Leuchter’s The Haunting feels less like attending a seance and more like flipping through the encyclopedia of a self.
iPhoto caption: Matthew MacKenzie and Mariya Khomutova in 'First Métis Man of Odesa' at Soulpepper Theatre in 2024. Photo by Dahlia Katz.
Theatre Calgary unveils 2026-27 season
Theatre Calgary has announced its 2026-27 lineup, including new productions of the musical Little Shop of Horrors and Sam Shepard’s drama True West.
iPhoto caption: Tara Sky and Emily Anne Corcoran in 'Julie.' Photo by Sandro Pehar.
REVIEW: Eros overpowers logos in Icarus Theatre’s Julie
Director Jordan Laffrenier focuses on atmosphere, delivering a heightened production that takes more from 1990s erotic thrillers than it does from naturalistic tragedy.
iPhoto caption: Photo Tarragon Theatre by Teagan McCanny.
Tarragon Theatre reveals premiere-packed 55th anniversary season, including return of Yaga and MONKS
Tarragon Theatre’s 2026-27 season features world premieres by Anahita Dehbonehie, Katherine Gauthier, Ho Ka Kei (Jeff Ho), and Luke Reece, plus four other Canadian works.
iPhoto caption: 'Une Traversée' puppet design by Natacha Belova et Tita Iacobelli. Photo by Pierre-Yves Jortay.
REVIEW: Montreal in March? Bring on the puppets.
The 21st annual Festival International de Casteliers featured an energizing series of Quebecois and European productions that took the medium of puppetry in surprising directions.
Comments