REVIEW: There are no words for Audra McDonald at Roy Thomson Hall
iPhoto caption: Photo by Jag Gundu
Any critic tasked with reviewing Audra McDonald must confront language’s inadequacy. Adjectives like “brilliant” and “heart-stopping” confuse her with the swaths of lesser performers who’ve been described similarly, flattening the matter. Her greatness is so established, so obvious, that such declarations feel empty. And yet to avoid them is to risk understatement.
Her touring concert An Evening with Audra McDonald, which played at Roy Thomson Hall on November 2 with the Toronto Symphony Orchestra, blurs descriptive poles: the singer’s manner is laid-back though poised, the selections predictable yet profound, her voice controlled but free. McDonald has collaborated with conductor Andy Einhorn for over a decade, and their act glistens with polish.
Perhaps unsurprisingly for a six-time Tony winner (the most of any actor), the concert includes many showtunes. Act One trends toward standards — “Summertime,” “It Don’t Mean a Thing (If It Ain’t Got That Swing),” “I Could Have Danced All Night” — while Act Two gets a bit more contemporary, to the point that it features a song found on R&B singer Emily King’s TikTok.
Much of the show orbits notions of childhood. McDonald sings “Pure Imagination” because she used to love Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, tells many a story about her four children, and invokes Kermit the Frog with a “Bein’ Green” cover. This exploration climaxes with a mash-up of “Carefully Taught” from Rodgers and Hammerstein’s South Pacific and “Children Will Listen” from Sondheim’s Into the Woods, two numbers highlighting how young people are shaped by their environments.
That song pairing has a hidden biographical resonance: Hammerstein was Sondheim’s writing mentor, his own careful teacher.
The program includes other subtle nods at the artistic lineage of American musical theatre. McDonald sings “Fable” from The Light in the Piazza — which, she points out, was written by Rodgers’ grandson, Adam Guettel. And a Bernstein medley (“Some Other Time” / “Somewhere”) follows a Sondheim one (“What Can You Lose?” / “Not A Day Goes By”), reminding us of the duo’s collaboration on West Side Story. This material is standard for a musical theatre concert, but it feels different in McDonald’s hands because she’s directly worked with many of these writers, making her part of the family. Especially in the case of Sondheim, her interpretations feel rooted in the man and his spirit (“We miss him terribly,” she says).
What gets me about McDonald is her phrasing. She’s performed most of this repertoire for several years, and her delivery is both sublime and mature. Whereas many musical theatre singers wander into vibrato haphazardly, spontaneously adding it halfway through a note, McDonald largely restricts such transitions to held-out vowels at the end of songs. Most other notes are either entirely straight, or entirely vibrato. This careful juxtaposition between (poppy) tension and (operatic) release gives McDonald’s storytelling its exhilarating texture.
An Evening with Audra McDonald includes a handful of songs from the singer’s most recent solo album, 2018’s Sing Happy. As the concert winds down, a thesis related to that title emerges: live in the moment. Love today. It’s not an original message; but with McDonald’s voice filling the air, it’s more achievable than ever.
An Evening with Audra McDonald played at Roy Thomson Hall on November 2. More information is available here.
Intermission reviews are independent and unrelated to Intermission’s partnered content. Learn more about Intermission’s partnership model here.
Liam Donovan
Liam is Intermission’s senior editor. He lives in Toronto. His Substack newsletter is available at loamdonovan.substack.com.
LEARN MORE
iPhoto caption: Devon Michael Brown as Rusty Charlie with members of the 'Guys and Dolls' company. Stratford Festival 2026. Photo by Ann Baggley.
“It's so exhausting, but it's really rewarding when you get to dance so full-out,” says Devon Michael Brown. “You get to use your technique and your training to the fullest extent.”
iPhoto caption: Ping-Hsiang Wang in 'Retina Maneuver.' Photo by Hang Su.
REVIEW: At this year’s SummerWorks Performance Festival, physical storytelling is central
From a dancer becoming a canine to a shy theatre director practicing his swordsmanship, the shows I’ve seen so far use performers’ bodies to dramatize defiance.
iPhoto caption: Anna Morreale and Luca McPhee perform in 'From Stardust' at the 2025 MADGEN Theatre Festival. Photo by Dave Klassen.
MADGEN Theatre Festival returns to the Danforth
Theatre of the Beat selected four producers under the age of 30 to receive paid mentorship from Toronto theatre-makers. From August 20 to 22, each member of the cohort mounts a new one-act Canadian play.
iPhoto caption: Steven Sutcliffe and company in 'Twelfth Night.' Photo by Dahlia Katz.
REVIEW: High Park Twelfth Night pays tribute to the crazy things we do for love
As the play’s events ping-pong between seriousness and frivolity, Caroline Toal’s Viola appears constantly aware of the dangerous contradictions in the air, remaining guarded against the chaos' pull — and yet never entirely abandoning the possibility of enchantment.
iPhoto caption: Paul Gross in 'Waiting for Godot.' Photo by David Hou.
Why Paul Gross thinks Waiting for Godot is ‘one of the great achievements of human creativity’
“The audience is with you. You bring them in. There isn't a big division between the stage and the audience,” says Gross, currently playing Vladimir in Waiting for Godot at the Stratford Festival. “They’re the final piece of the storytelling. We need them to complete the circle.”
iPhoto caption: Karl Ang, Ivy Charles, Daniel Maslany, Mariya Khomutova, and Alon Nashman in 'The Division.' Photo by Dahlia Katz.
Productions at Crow’s and Theatre Passe Muraille win top honours at the 2026 Dora Awards
This evening at Meridian Hall, the Toronto Alliance for the Performing Arts (TAPA) announced the recipients of the 46th annual Dora Awards, celebrating local theatre, dance, and opera.
Comments