REVIEW: Maggie at Theatre Aquarius

Photo by Dahlia Katz

I’ve often wondered what it was like to see the earliest draft of Come From Away — what was the energy in the room? How has the blockbuster musical evolved since that first outing? Did that audience know how special that piece of theatre would become?

Someday, I think critics and historians might wonder the same about Maggie, now playing in its world premiere at Theatre Aquarius in Hamilton.

With music, book, lyrics, and real-life inspiration from country singer Johnny Reid (with help from Matt Murray and Bob Foster), Maggie is a love letter to working-class Scotland, a tribute to Reid’s grandmother, and a wrenching tale of perseverance and love. Though set in Lanark, a small, industrial town between Glasgow and Edinburgh, the musical speaks to a much larger geography, asking sharp questions about what happens when people migrate from their hometowns, as well as what happens when they stay there. As a product of Sheridan College’s late mamented Canadian Music Theatre Project, you can be sure there’s a Canadian reference or two in there, as well.

It’s 1954 in Lanark, and our heroine Maggie (a wickedly talented Dharma Bizier) is pregnant and in love with her husband. That’s more than most of the women of Lanark can say — at best they seem to tolerate the men in their lives — but immediately it’s clear Maggie has a strong community of lasses ready to support her through her journey into motherhood.

She’ll need that support, it turns out. We meet her husband for only a moment, and he never gets to parent his three boys: Shug, Tommy, and Jimmy (the well cast, highly compelling Lawrence Libor, William Lincoln, and Aidan Burke, respectively).

A wee time-jump later, it’s 1968, and the boys are nearly grown, exploring different interests and wondering what their futures might look like. The world around them is suffocatingly small, and they all have dreams far larger than Lanark, but they also understand the life-and-death stakes of the divide between Catholics and Protestants. That schism, in fact, dominates their everyday lives: one can hardly buy a drink or play a game of football without the religious and cultural looming over their heads.

So goes Maggie. As the matriarch ages, so do her sons, and so does the splintering, hotly political world around them. As time goes on, Maggie suffers unimaginable loss, having to reckon with just how far a mother’s love can stretch — both emotionally and geographically. Throughout it all, though, Maggie has that rock-solid community of women around her, mothers and friends who put the kettle on for her when she needs it most. Sadie (a funny and strongly voiced Jamie McRoberts) leads the chorus of women as they come to grips with themselves and their place in the world, rallying around Maggie, yes, but equally coming together to ensure a more equitable future for their small town.

The Theatre Aquarius run is a first outing for Maggie. It shows. There’s much to be wowed by in the production — an ensemble of actors who have nailed a tricky accent, and Mary Francis Moore’s sensible, well paced direction — but there are structural bumps to iron out before Maggie heads off to Prince Edward Island this summer (and perhaps down Mirvish Way after that; it’s a fair guess, given the musical’s feel-good glow). Maggie is ably sung and often smartly composed, but the rhythm of the book stumbles a few times. Our lovely, commanding protagonist has a few confessional songs, one of which appears oddly early on in the show. While “Unbreakable” is a tight, powerful ballad, it’s also unearned so early in the narrative thrust of the story — we’ve not yet learned that Maggie is unbreakable, so it seems the song might be better placed later on, once we’ve had the chance to see that strength for ourselves. It seems “Unbreakable” was a late addition, sometime after the creation of the show’s cast recording — there’s time yet to find a more impactful place for it in the show.

Generally, as well, Reid’s uptempo songs are more memorable than the ballads and the musical connective tissue between them. “Friday Night In Lanark” and “Queen For a Day” are very, very good, the former as captivating an opening number as Come From Away’s “Welcome to the Rock.” As well, Maggie’s emotional songs tend to pack more of a punch than those written for her sons. There’s room, too, for more underscoring between musical numbers, making for a more cohesive, less stop-and-start show.

Technically, Maggie’s in tip-top shape, from Ken MacDonald’s inventive set, which perfectly captures the rowhomes of working-class Scotland, to Samantha McCue’s bang-on costumes, which suggest time and place so well one wonders if a few of the time-stamping references in the book might not be necessary. Kimberly Purtell’s lights, too, are original and effective, drawing focus to imagined places onstage without distracting from MacDonald’s set.

With a few tweaks, Maggie could be well on its way to becoming Canada’s next musical theatre phenomenon. It’s got the cast, it’s got the aesthetics, and it’s got the heart — already I can confidently say it’s the show in the GTA you should take your mom to if you can. With just a few snips, additions, and rearrangements in the book, Maggie will be a real force to reckon with once it hits bigger stages in bigger cities — and Bizier might just be seeing herself on a Broadway marquee in a few years’ time.

Maggie runs at Theatre Aquarius until May 6. Tickets are available here.

3 Responses to “REVIEW: Maggie at Theatre Aquarius”

  1. Just seen Maggie this evening I left the theatre thinking with some revisions this is a “Come from Away” presentation with a difference. This is personal, but most of all the celebration of the sacrifices mothers will make for their children. As an immigrants of many years ago I ached during the leaving of her son to America. The tempo the lyrics and the presentation we are going to hear about for years to come

  2. Where do I fit in MAGGIE? But just being dragged into human JOY, DRAMA, HURT, HOPE, and friendships!
    It is all there with original music, strongly performed songs and acting. A story in which you feel you are a part of it. You bring the well written script back home with you in your veins after this entertaining play that is MAGGIE !! Bravo Maggie ( Dharma Bizier) for reaching out the intensity of HER story !!!

  3. I am visiting PEI and saw Maggie last night (Jul12) Admittedly, I was a wee bit skeptical at first but wow, did I soon become entranced in the performance.
    Dharma’s performance was wonderful.
    I read a Globe review that wasn’t so positive and I truly think the reviewer just didn’t get it! Working it’s way through the decades worked well. The storyline and situational innuendos were obvious if you were paying attention. Johnny Reid and team – Bravo! I will recommend this to Everyone I know.

Leave a Reply

We’d love to hear from you! Feel free to leave a comment below, but please read our conditions first: 1) Be respectful, 2) Please don’t spam us, 3) We will remove any comments that contain hate speech, pornography, harassment, personal attacks, defamatory statements, or threats. Thanks for your understanding.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written By

Aisling is Intermission's senior editor, a breaking news reporter at CP24, and a former reporter for the Toronto Star. She is former president of the Canadian Theatre Critics Association. She likes British playwright Sarah Kane, most songs by Taylor Swift, and her cats, Fig and June.